The Sing Off - XF, do you like the new way they do the sing off?

XF, do you like the new way they do the sing off?

i think it is a much better idea to let them sing a song of their choosing, that way nobody can blame a bad song. it makes it much fairer.

Public Comments

Yes....then they can try to give their all with something they are use to.
Yes I agree and it means if the category that week doesn't suit them they have a second chance.
No it's just a feeble attempt to make that cr@p more interesting so it's literally like polishing a turd.
Yes, it's a lot better the way it's done now.
Yes love it... bring's out the real talent .... me think's
yeah i agree, at least if they had a bad song before they couldnt blame it on thier mentor as they chose the song that mattered the most! : )
Yes I think it's a much better idea. If they're in the bottom two their first song mustn't have been up to much.
Yes but that's only good for the judges because the public vote on what they saw during the main show.
Yes I agree with you and it gives more variety to the show as well.
yes it was so much better - gives them abetter chance to sow there talents
Yeah, I think that it's great, because they can do what they want so it's going to be easier for them, and also there's no gimmicks only them singing, and that really shows how good they are.
Yes definitely an improvement Doobs and much fairer as you say. I do think the whole public vote though is so predictable and biased - we just knew it would be girl bands in the sing off because nobody votes for them. As it is usually young girls who vote I can only conclude it must be jealousy or a preference for the young fit lads! It should be about talent though fair and square.
I much prefer this new way, especially if the judges have given them an awful song choice they have the chance to redeem themselves.
Yeah Doobs, it is a far better idea. It gives them the chance to show what they are capable of - going to be relevant in this series, if the song choices continue like last nights!!!!!!!
yes as they can sing within their comfort zone and what may have been ccrap before they could save themselves with good song.
I do Doobs, it's a much needed improvement !!