The Sing Off

X Factor: If Mary and Katie are in the sing off tomorrow...?

What would your reaction be if Katie got saved over Mary? I would stop watching. It wasn't Mary's best week but at least she can actually sing unlike Katie. If Katie got saved it would prove the X Factor is a popularity-with-the-judges contest.

Public Comments

1. It would be unfair, because it would be Katie's 3rd time in the bottom 2 and she's not as strong as Mary
2. It would be SO unfair, Mary is AMAZING. Though I thought when Katie did King of the Swingers she was pretty damn good as well, but other weeks she was totally pants. I wanted to go on the X Factor but going on The Apprentice got in the way.
3. It would be unfair, but I doubt that will happen. It'll either be her or Wagner. I want Wagner to leave first, but it doesn't matter because she'll go eventually.
4. LOL at Sandeesh And yeh it would be unfair and it wouldnt happen.
5. i think the judges would choose mary anyway. because katie has been there before.
6. If Katie is in the bottom 2 with anybody it would be unfair to save Katie as she has been their twice already. They can't keep on saving her as she will go eventually.
7. I think if that happened it'd be incredibly unfair. And I'm a fan of both! It'd be Katie's 3rd time in the sing off. She's had some good performances, but the UK public just aren't warming up to her. They don't 'want' to vote for her. It'd be unfair to keep Katie, who'd probably end up in the bottom again the following week, over Mary who's been consistently good every week (this week she was 'meh' but she's only human). To kick Mary off for one mediocre night would be evil. She has so much more to offer! That being said, I think Mary should step it up. She was the showstopper of the first Live Show and hasn't had that same magic since then. She's been good, but not as awesome as that first night. She should do some more soul!!!
8. Hey If mary is going to be in the bottom 2 tonight i think its going to be a shock to everyone. if mary is going to be up against katie nd katie goes through to nxt week, its going to be fix nd they will be outraged left , right nd centre. it will show that the x factor is based on performances only and not on ppl who can actually sing also it will show that the other judges(cheryl,simon nd danni) doesnt want her there as they know that mary could win it for ireland. I agree it wasnt mary's best week but she can totally sing 100 times better than katie, katie is a drama queen with a squeaking voice who can't sing a song in tune.
9. It really should be Katie and Wagner, they are both horrendous!